| 2002-2003 |
| Mark Tampow |
Bellville Althoff |
Blackburn College |
| |
| 2003-2004 |
| Jacob Bayers |
Freeburg |
Harris-Stowe State College |
| Tyler Heck |
Centralia |
Purdue University |
| |
| 2004-2005 |
| Will Capie |
Carterville |
Southern Illinois University at Carbondale |
| Todd Harpstrite |
Wesclin |
McKendree University |
| John Piatt |
O'Fallon |
Central Methodist University |
| |
| 2005-2006 |
| Ben Boehne |
Nashville |
Indiana University Purdue University at Fort Wayne |
| Chris Enegle |
Nashville |
Southern Illinois University at Carbondale |
| Brian Ganey |
Sacred Heart-Griffin |
Southern Illinois University at Carbondale |
| Craig Moffett |
Stewardson-Strasburg |
William Woods University |
| (Academic All-American Team for 2006) |
| |
| 2006-2007 |
| Jason Kloibhofer |
Saunders |
Warner Southern University |
| Calvin O'Rear |
Nashville |
McKendree University |
| Jay Voss |
Breese Mater Dei |
Southern Illinois University at Carbondale |
| Scott Wells |
M.M. Robinson |
Indiana University Purdue University at Fort Wayne |
| Marcus Wilson |
Arthur |
Delta State University |
| (Academic All-American Team for 2007) |
| |
| 2007-2008 |
| Jared Fisher |
Okawville |
Quincy University |
| Nathan Forer |
Mayfield |
Southern Illinois University at Carbondale |
| Tyler Graham |
St. Michaels |
Indiana State University |
| Jason Sullivan |
Shelbyville |
Western Carolina University |
| (Academic All-American Team for 2008) |